Scary Stories #9: Muahaha!


Episode #904

Date October 30, 2017

Run Time 1:41:21

Robin Reiser, Ansley Isham, Kristen Ludwig, Burke Heffner and Erika Steigerwald share scary stories in our 2017 Halloween episode.

Song: RISK! MASH! by Jeff Barr and Bobby “Boris” Pickett & The Crypt-Kickers

Song: The Munsters Theme by Los Straitjackets

Live Story: Lady in the Room by Robin Reiser

Interstitial: Is This Scary? by JJ Evans and Jeff Barr

Radio Story: The Siege by Ansley Isham

Interstitial: Got a Rock? by Jeff Barr

Live Story: Mr. Francois by Kristen Ludwig

Song: Heads Will Roll by Yeah Yeah Yeahs

Live Story with Sound Design: Below Zero by Burke Heffner

Interstitial: What’s He Building in There by Tom Waits

Radio Story: Your Health and Your Soul by Erika Steigerwald

Song: Black Magic Woman by Santana


Want to hear more spooky stories? Find all our of Scary Stories episodes here!




Download: MP3

Notify of

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
6 years ago

Best one yet. Ghosts, home invasion, serial killers, mother nature, and exorcism – what more could you ask for?

6 years ago

Was that a witch cackling during the first story? Very on-theme.

Simone de la Espriella
6 years ago

Robin, I loved your story. I grew up in a haunted house too and my grandma also called a priest to “clean” it. Still laughing!!!

6 years ago

The woman in the exorcist story should lose all medical qualifications and I hope she is never allowed near patients again. It is one thing for randos to believe this BS or make up stories about it, but she can clearly do real harm and is delegitimating her entire profession.

6 years ago

The final storyteller is no longer in that line of work. She even explains in the story that her perspective is not kosher in that line of work. Something I say constantly on the podcast and everywhere the podcast is talked about is this: we ask the storytellers to present what they personally interpret to be what they personally experienced. We don’t necessarily endorse anything they say. We don’t necessarily condone their philosophies or choices. We don’t present anything as if our show is journalism or trial-worthy testimony. We all doubt or disagree with some of the things some of the people say on the show.

6 years ago

What happened to the rest of Erika’s story???? It cuts off!!!!!!

6 years ago

Erika’s story got cut off! Where can we finish the episode?

6 years ago

The last story cut off right at the scariest point!

6 years ago

Please update Ericka’s story it gets cut off at the best part

6 years ago

Hey guys, there was a technical difficulty with the episode today. If you refresh, it should all be there now.

6 years ago

oh thank god. I was worried it was some sick halloween prank….. lolllll

6 years ago
6 years ago

Erika’s story really scared me. And hearing it, I trusted her judgment and her take on what happened (in response to the comment above…). There are so many things we don’t know and that is what is interesting about hearing these stories, we learn about different perspectives and experiences and I love the fact that it broadens my understanding of the human experience.
I loved Robin’s story and had goosebumps all over when she described how she met this random stranger so far away from home who randomly asked her where she was from and randomly said they’d call his wife… wow, for me, it feels like it was no coincidence and that the man’s wife needed the message Robin delivered and that some angels made that happen. Love it.

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x